« less than... | Main | realize you're living in the golden years »

Somebody please put baby in the corner.

Lately, I can’t open a magazine, hit a website, or overhear hoboes talking without hearing about "disposable formats". Everyone’s up in arms about what is the disposable format – “make music online only; save the industry”, “crack down on illegal downloading; save the industry”, “think green, no jewel case; use an eco-pak”, “those blintzes were terrible”.

I don’t think CDs are disposable, but CD singles are done. They’re dead as…dead, and there’s no excuse for the screw job anybody growing up in the 90’s had to endure. I remember paying up to $16.99 for an Ash single, just to own three songs that were b-sides. Songs that, right out of the gate, can be deemed inferior to the rest of a bands oeuvre. People mention Oasis and the quality of their B-sides, but Noel Gallagher has admitted that he did that on purpose (saving some single-worthy tracks for b-sides), just so we suckers would believe that he was a genius. That’s also why, incidentally, The Masterplan is Oasis’ best album.

Anyway, I’m digressing in my first paragraph but, believe it or not, I'm going somewhere with this. The first time I heard Sloan’s “I Am the Cancer”; I heard the rarer acoustic version of the song from Sloan’s Live at a Sloan Party, a CD that was included as a U.S. incentive to buy their One Chord To Another album. I remember thinking “Wow, this doesn’t sound like Sloan”. I, at that time, had perceived Sloan to be…well…a bunch of dorks. When I bought Smeared and heard this version, I liked it more. It sounded “cool”.

Sloan - I Am The Cancer

It’s still my favorite song of theirs, so when I found a copy of the I Am The Cancer single, I bought it. “Why do you want that Sloan single?” the entire staff of Zero (a.k.a. Kam) asked. Two reasons:

1. One weird trend I have in “collecting” is that if there’s a possible way to own a single for my favourite song by a band, I usually go to great lengths to do so. I have no idea why. Perhaps I’m trying to prove to the song that I like it best. I want it to know, so I single it out, spend money on it, and…kiss it. Or something. There’s one example of this that cost me a little too much money, and anyone who knows me can probably guess what band it was and what song it was for.

2. Sloan singles are pretty hard to come by, and I dig the fact that they used to do stuff like this; the b-side of the single I bought:

Sloan - Rag Doll

They were flat out trying to sound like My Bloody Valentine. They were trying to be cool. That’s really endearing. Most people don’t know this side of Sloan, and that’s cool. The problem is that it seems like every time a band is trying to find their footing, or trying to sound cool, it’s archived on the goddamn “Waybackmachine”. I guess I’m just saying that no format is disposable, as MP3s are superb for their utter randomness, CD singles for their forgotten 4th tracks and CDs for their…omnipresence?

Except for 3” CD singles; that’s just fucking garbage.

Spend money on Smeared by a bunch of dorks.

-Kevin

Comments (6)

kam:

Despite my incredulity at purchasing the single, I love "I am The Cancer", and had been listening to it incessantly this past week. Actually, someone who responded to my mixed-cd plea will have it on their's. Be forewarned.

You're more collector than I, so it makes sense. To me, when it comes to CDs, I'm about the album as a whole, and always found CD singles like shareware; they served their purpose, but were a fragmented tease. And true enough, like shareware, singles are pretty much out of circulation, thanks to the internet.

But welcome back! See, everyone? See! We didn't break up.

Old married couples never break up. They just continue to grow old and bitter together.

Well done Kevin.

Scott:

It's funny - I'm STILL an incessant single collector... with one of my fav bands annoyingly releasing a number of vinyl only 7" tracks. What makes it worse (and here we disagree) is I think some of my fav bands have BETTER b-sides than album tracks.

The Cure are an easy example - with 5 song swaps of b-sides in lieu of album tracks Wild Mood Swings would not be a cheapie bin filler CD (as it has become) but could stand beside Wish as a melancholy pop masterpiece.

And Grandaddy. *sigh* To the point that one of my all time favourite songs (and this is by no means an attempt at indie cred) was released ONLY on vinyl and ONLY as a freebie with an indier-than thou magazine (Devil In The Woods) and limited to 650-odd copies.

(The song is Aisle Seat 37-D for anyone who cares).

But nice score on "I Am The Cancer"...

Eric:

I listened to this track on the hype machine hoping beyond hope that the distortion at the end would break into the "fame and fortune don't interest me, just as long as I have you" accompanying song. I had a mixed tape with a bunch of covers, demos, and unreleased stuff but lost it in a move. Any chance of posting more, such as the aforementioned song?

Good job with this one.

Kevin:

Eric - Check your e-mail.

Scott - Yes, there are bands whose b-sides are sometimes better than their album tracks, but generally, b-sides are stereotyped as being the lesser of a band's songs (right or wrong). Sloan would definitly be one of those bands in which that holds true. You're right about the Cure. The Exploding Boy and Sugar Girl are two of my favourite Cure tracks. And Jeane by the Smiths? Brilliance.

Scott:

I think I'm just biased since all my fav bands have BRILLIANT b-sides. Some filler, for sure, but by and large when they release (or I compile) b-sides collections - they're as good (sometimes better) than albums:

Cure
Echo & The Bunnymen
Depeche Mode (too many instrumentals, but vocal b-sides just as good)
Underworld
Grandaddy
Blur
The Jesus & Mary Chain
Adorable (you KNOW I'm right [smirk])
Peter Gabriel

etc etc

But I get what you're saying - as I said, I'm biased by a REALLY strong sample group LOL!

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on May 14, 2007 12:34 AM.

The previous post in this blog was less than....

The next post in this blog is realize you're living in the golden years.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.